I'm still not getting alerts for new topics that have been created or activity on threads I've replied in unless I'm specifically tagged.
Although I just found a new checkbox in the "Look & Layout" section of my profile. I checked off, "Show most recent posts at the top in topic view" to see if that helps.
EDIT: That did not work. It just made each thread descending order instead of ascending.
It all used to be in a clickable button at the top right where the "Alerts" button used to be.
UPDATE: I just saw a setting that maybe might help? I set it to give me alerts of replies and moderation. Also, something I never noticed before was on the top right of each individual board is a button for alerts. I went ahead and told it to give me alerts when something happens in that specific board.
EDIT: That did not work. It just made each thread descending order instead of ascending.
It all used to be in a clickable button at the top right where the "Alerts" button used to be.
UPDATE: I just saw a setting that maybe might help? I set it to give me alerts of replies and moderation. Also, something I never noticed before was on the top right of each individual board is a button for alerts. I went ahead and told it to give me alerts when something happens in that specific board.